WP1 – HOLISTIC ASSESSMENT
Output 1.2. Parametric life cycle assessment or wind turbines returns lower impacts than current data

Ecoinvent’s inventories for 800 kW (Nordex N50/800), 2 MW (Vestas V80/2.0) and 4.5 MW (Enercon E-112) are based on outdated data and have assumptions that would not be realistic for generic turbines of these sizes. Namely, incineration of copper at the end of life, direct land use intensities below those reported in dedicated reports, asphalt access roads and a concrete tower for the 4.5 MW turbine. The implications of these assumptions are notably seen in the Figure, where we compare the environmental impacts (ReCiPe 2016 v1.1 midpoint (H)) of Ecoinvent’s and WindTrace’s inventories in terms of climate change, freshwater ecotoxiticy and land use. The discrepancies are as large as 16-times higher impacts in Freshwater Ecotoxicity in Ecoinvent compared to WindTrace, for example. We argue that the use WindTrace offers greater flexibility by allowing key parameters to be adjusted, which makes it more suitable to create generalized turbines in different settings.
Reference: Sierra-Montoya et al. 2025. WindTrace: a parametric life-cycle inventory model for wind energy.
Output 1.2. There is a need for indicators that join social and ecological aspects

Currently, the most widely used approach for the assessment of environmental and social impacts of prospective energy system configurations is ex-post simulation with Life Cycle Assessment (LCA). However, LCA does not provide a thorough analysis of the socio-ecological impacts of the energy transition -impacts for both systems combined. To fill this gap, we are adapting the Environmental and Bioeconomic System Analysis module (ENBIOS) to increase its resolution and improve its capabilities for the assessment of wind power. ENBIOS integrates LCA with the Multi-Scale Integrated Assessment of Socio-Ecosystem Metabolism (MuSIASEM) framework, that helps us connect the energy sector with other socio-ecological functions and allow us to assess holistic impacts on the socio-ecosystem.
Reference: Madrid-López et al. 2025. The Environmental and Bioeconomic Assessment Module. (ENBIOS): adaptation for wind power.



